If she’s amazing, she won’t be easy. If she’s easy, she won’t be amazing.
If she’s worth it, you won’t give up. If you give up, you’re not worthy…”
– Bob Marley
We were set up by a mutual friend. He called me during the blizzard. We made a date for the following weekend. I was so excited. We met at a sherry bar, and the moment I saw him, I knew. I just knew. The date was wonderful, magical. We moved on from that bar to another. We drank some more. We talked about wanting to travel with someone special, he said he was going to go renew his passport right away. We talked about marriage – he put my first name with his last, and his eyes danced at the prospect of our future together. Neither of us wanted the night to end. He walked me out to my Uber and we kissed. He took my breath away. I got into the car and simply sparkled.
He kept gazing at me and finally said,
“You’ll have to get used to me staring at you. I can’t take my eyes off you.”
“I can stare at your lovely face forever.”
We had a date two nights later. And then on Friday night. Then we found a way to meet up the next night. He wanted to take me away for Valentine’s Day. I spent the night with him, despite only knowing him for a week but when I woke up still wrapped in his arms, I knew.
Valentine’s Day was romantic, away on the Eastern Shores, taking advantage of the spa with massages and just… well, you know.
And so it went. One Friday night the following month we went to dinner downtown. We were seated in a quiet corner of the restaurant. He said, “Anybody watching us would think we’re in love.” I was. Completely. He had our waiter take a photo of us. It’s still my favorite photo – we were both madly, crazy in love.
“I don’t care if Monday’s blue
Tuesday’s gray and Wednesday, too
Thursday, I don’t care about you
It’s Friday, I’m in love”
– The Cure
And so it went on that way. We spent days and nights and weekends and weekend nights adoring each other. He even made our relationship “official” by formally asking me to be his girlfriend.
He would tell me how perfect I am.
How sweet and beautiful and wonderful I am.
He would tell me that he wants to be a good man. My man.
We had our intimate jokes about our future in the old age home.
He told me that I’m a classic beauty and I’ll never get old.
He told me I’m the perfect size when we hug or snuggle.
He told me he wants us to eventually live together.
He told me he wants us to elope one day.
He told me I’m perfect.
We drove to Cleveland and stayed at my parents’ house. He witnessed my mother’s crazy song and dance in which she one-sidedly argued politics, religion, the plight of the Jews, the mistreatment of those under Soviet control. But we made it back.
It’s been a hot summer. Uncomfortably hot, forcing us indoors with the AC blasting. Maybe we were getting stir crazy. Maybe I was getting tired of being the one to always plan outings and buy tickets and make reservations. Maybe I was already losing him…
Maybe I made the mistake of opening up to him and trusting him with my fears about my new job, wondering if I’ve been making the right career decisions for the last decade. I told him I’ve worked so hard my entire life and maybe I was getting burnt out. I needed a vacation. Maybe I made the mistake of telling him how I’ve been flying solo for most of my life – only child, changed schools a few times, moved around – and I envied those with lifelong friends or friends in every corner of the world, such as him. I was a little bummed but I’m not depressed. But you know what? He was my boyfriend. He was supposed to give me a big hug and a kiss and tell me I’m brilliant and awesome and everything is going to be fine at work, and I’ll find that new apartment soon, and yes my mom is insane but it’s okay, everything is okay, he’s there to support me. Instead, he told me how I could benefit from therapy. That’s when I felt like he was already headed toward the door…
He went on a week-long trip for a couple of conferences out of town, after leaving me fraught with nerves, scared that he’s scared, anxious because he told me he’s anxious, but didn’t tell me exactly why. He came back and we had plans for Tuesday:
“Are you still coming over?”
I told him yes, and asked what he wanted to do.
“Just a quiet dinner, maybe watch a movie.”
Nervous, scared, and anxious, I asked if I should pack an overnight bag.
“I thought that goes without saying.”
I rushed home and got my stuff together and Ubered over to his place. I stood outside his apartment door, heart pounding, feeling the blood drain down… down… down…
I wanted to tell him all the fun and crazy things that happened while he was away. I wanted to tell him that the week to myself was a good thing, and I feel amazing and I can’t wait for our trip to the beach the following week to just relax, lay back, and enjoy ourselves away from this insane city.
I finally knocked on the door. He opened it in his timid way – peering out before fully opening the door. I couldn’t act happy and natural. I felt it coming… He tried to act normal. I came in, put my bag down and plopped down on the couch. We barely made any small talk when he blurted out
“I’m not feeling good.”
I asked if he caught a cold on the plane and started to tell him about the bout of e. coli I experienced earlier last week until he interrup–
“No. I’m not feeling good about this. About us.”
I stared. The room began to darken quickly as the sun went down.
“Do you think we’re okay?”
Yes, I told him. Maybe we hit a rough patch but it’s nothing we can’t work out. In fact, I wanted to sa–
“I WANT PERFECT AND YOU’RE NOT PERFECT!”
The room suddenly faded into shades of gray. My heart stopped beating and I felt the air rush out of my body. This isn’t really happening. No. It can’t be. No. No. No. No! NO! NO!NO!NO!NO!NO!NO!NO!!!!!NO!NO!NO!NO!!!!!
“I just want easy.”
The rest of it was a blur. It was all confusing. He was confused. He didn’t want to make a decision he was going to regret in a month. He just needed to sleep on it and see how he feels in the morning. He left me with nothing to go on. He left me with no words. He left me with no comfort. He left me with nothing. I left his apartment.
Bits and pieces of his soliloquy float around in my head…
“Why have I never been compelled to buy you flowers?” “I’m just anxious…”
“I don’t know…” “This is why I’m bad at relationships.”
“At 6 months I should have stronger feelings.”
“I care about you so, so, so much.” “You’re such a sweet girl”
“I think you may be a depressed person.” “You’re not perfect.“
I managed to go to work the next morning. I met with clients and when I got back into my car, I saw that he texted me.
“Are you ok?”
I didn’t know how to respond to that. I told him so. I started my car and drove back to my office. I parked and looked at my phone again.
“I know. I’m sorry, I was just thinking about you.”
I went off on him. I asked him if he really expected me to be okay. I asked him if he realized that I’ve spent hours wondering what I did wrong, where did I mess up, what’s wrong with me. I told him that I was mad at myself for giving so much to him. I was profoundly bereft and pissed off and crying in my car. Yeah, I was okay.
“I don’t expect you to be ok. It hurts me to hear all of this. I hope eventually, not now but eventually, you can appreciate that I’m trying to be honest about my feelings.”
I went off on him again. I told him I felt like I never stood a chance and now he’s happy and free and I have to pick up the pieces. I told him that his pithy line about hoping that I’ll appreciate his honesty one day was lame.
He never did explain what he meant by anxious, by the way.
He once said he was anxious about his life,
whether he’s letting his life pass him by,
whether he’s saving enough in his retirement accounts,
about his aging parents 2,000 miles away,
whether he wants to be a father.
But that’s life, isn’t it?
That’s all of our worries.
But we keep going, right?
I took the afternoon off from work. I canceled our hotel reservations on the shore. I canceled my PTO request. I stopped eating and started chain smoking. I decided to write a letter, spilling all my feelings and everything I wanted to say but was never given a chance. I regrettably mailed it to him. One week later, he texted
“I’m on the plane, about to take off. I got your letter, it looks like you may have sent it a while ago but I don’t check my mail often. Just wanted to acknowledge that I got it, and it was very meaningful. I care about you so much, but I still feel the same way that last time we spoke.”
He texted from a plane about to take off??? I call BS on not having checked the mail. I deserved a PHONE CALL. I spill my heart out and he texts me from a plane so if I even wanted to reply I couldn’t??? He made me feel like I was trying to sell him a car, or a set of Encyclopedia Britannica. I never replied. I never saw him again.
“The biggest coward is a man who awakens a woman’s love with no intention of loving her.”
– maybe Bob Marley
It’s been a month and half, give or take. I have a lot more bad days lately than I should. I need to get over him. I wonder if he’s already with someone else. I wonder if he actually left me for someone else. I wonder if he thinks about me. There are too many days when I wish he’d call or just show up and tell me he wants me back. There are too many days when I have to tell myself that he’s a jerk, and he doesn’t deserve me. I wonder if he’ll wish me a happy birthday in a couple of weeks. I wonder what he told his family and friends and what they told him. I wonder where I went wrong and have to stop blaming myself. I cry too often, still. I don’t wish him ill, but I don’t wish him well. I wish him back and I wish the pain would just go away. I’m still profoundly bereft and pissed off, but I still love him. I wish he loves me back.